NHL Scores · NHL Odds

Maple Leafs vs Islanders

Final/OT · Sat Jan 3 · 7:00 PM ET · UBS Arena

Toronto Maple LeafsMaple Leafs19-15-7
3
Final/OTJan 3, 2026
New York IslandersIslanders23-15-4
4
TVNHL NetMSGSN

Closing line

US sportsbook at puck drop
Moneyline
TOR−115
NYI−105
Puck line
TOR −1.5+225
NYI +1.5−278
Total O/U
Over 5.5−120
Under 5.5+100
  • Puck line: Islanders +1.5 covered.
  • Total O/U: over 5.5 (7 goals).

Recap

The New York Islanders beat the Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3 in overtime at UBS Arena in Elmont on Jan 3, 2026 to move to 23-15-4.

The go-ahead score came with 4:11 left in overtime: Matthew Schaefer Goal (12) Snap Shot, assists: Mathew Barzal (22), Emil Heineman (7).

Score by period

Toronto Maple Leafs and New York Islanders, score by period
Team123OTT
TOR02103
NYI01214

W: Rittich · L: Woll

Scoring plays

Second Period

  1. NYIGoal · 1:10Adam Pelech Goal (3) Wrist Shot, assists: Jonathan Drouin (15)0-1
  2. TORGoal · 9:30Auston Matthews Goal (19) Wrist Shot, assists: none1-1
  3. TORGoal · 17:19Auston Matthews Goal (20) Snap Shot, assists: Bobby McMann (10), Max Domi (15)2-1

Third Period

  1. NYIGoal · 11:10Matthew Schaefer Goal (11) Wrist Shot, assists: Jonathan Drouin (16), Jean-Gabriel Pageau (10)2-2
  2. TORGoal · 12:12Nicholas Robertson Goal (9) Snap Shot, assists: Nicolas Roy (11)3-2
  3. NYIGoal · 17:15Emil Heineman Goal (13) Snap Shot, assists: Mathew Barzal (21), Tony DeAngelo (13)3-3

Overtime

  1. NYIGoal · 4:11Matthew Schaefer Goal (12) Snap Shot, assists: Mathew Barzal (22), Emil Heineman (7)3-4

Team stats

TORNYI
Shots
21
25
Power Play Goals
0
0
Faceoff Win Percent
57.1
42.9
Hits
19
21
Blocked Shots
11
11
Penalty Minutes
4
4

Top performers

Toronto Maple LeafsNew York Islanders

Goals

Auston Matthews2
Matthew Schaefer2

Assists

Max Domi1
Mathew Barzal2

Points

Auston Matthews2
Matthew Schaefer2

Player stats

Maple Leafs · Forwards

PlayerBSHTTK+/-TOIGASSOGFO%PIM
Easton Cowan RW040111:5800100.00
Max Domi C000017:2101000.02
Calle Jarnkrok C000010:4200000.00
Matthew Knies LW010-219:0300000.00
Scott Laughton C120014:20003060.00
Steven Lorentz C000012:0500200.00
Matias Maccelli LW000-116:5500100.00
Auston Matthews C200022:29206040.00
Bobby McMann C200020:1701000.00
Nick Robertson LW000112:0210200.00
Nicolas Roy C010111:42012075.00
John Tavares C000-217:04001068.82

Maple Leafs · Defense

PlayerBSHTTK+/-TOIGASSOGFO%PIM
Matt Benning D300012:2600000.00
Simon Benoit D170015:4400000.00
Oliver Ekman-Larsson D110226:4000000.00
Jake McCabe D111218:0700100.00
Morgan Rielly D020-427:3100100.00
Troy Stecher D001-122:0700100.00

Maple Leafs · Goalies

PlayerGASASVSV%TOIPIM
Joseph Woll G42521.84064:110

Islanders · Forwards

PlayerBSHTTK+/-TOIGASSOGFO%PIM
Mathew Barzal C102122:49022047.12
Casey Cizikas C031013:12000033.30
Jonathan Drouin LW100218:56021025.00
Marc Gatcomb C270013:1600100.00
Emil Heineman LW020-120:1111200.00
Simon Holmstrom RW100218:4500300.00
Anders Lee LW010-115:34001075.00
Kyle MacLean C010010:1500100.00
Jean-Gabriel Pageau C110118:30012053.80
Calum Ritchie C000-19:10002016.70
Maxim Shabanov RW010-115:0400200.00
Maxim Tsyplakov RW010010:10000050.00

Islanders · Defense

PlayerBSHTTK+/-TOIGASSOGFO%PIM
Tony DeAngelo D000322:4201200.00
Scott Mayfield D111-219:0900100.00
Cole McWard D111-214:5000000.00
Adam Pelech D110124:0410200.00
Ryan Pulock D100019:4500100.02
Matthew Schaefer D111122:1120200.00

Islanders · Goalies

PlayerGASASVSV%TOIPIM
David Rittich G32118.85764:110

Three stars

  1. Matthew Schaefer (NYI)
  2. Auston Matthews (TOR)
  3. Jonathan Drouin (NYI)

Scores, stats and closing line: ESPN. Prediction-market prices: Kalshi and Polymarket. Betting splits: a consensus across several sportsbooks. Odds change constantly: confirm the price at the book. 21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Game details updated Oct 13, 6:03 PM ET. How game pages are made