NHL Scores · NHL Odds

Penguins vs Islanders

Final/OT · Tue Feb 3 · 7:30 PM ET · UBS Arena

Pittsburgh PenguinsPenguins28-15-12
4
Final/OTFeb 3, 2026
New York IslandersIslanders31-21-5
5
TVTNTtruTVStreamHBO Max

Closing line

US sportsbook at puck drop
Moneyline
PIT−120
NYI+100
Puck line
PIT −1.5+220
NYI +1.5−270
Total O/U
Over 5.5−108
Under 5.5−112
  • Puck line: Islanders +1.5 covered.
  • Total O/U: over 5.5 (9 goals).

Recap

The New York Islanders beat the Pittsburgh Penguins 5-4 in overtime at UBS Arena in Elmont on Feb 3, 2026 to move to 31-21-5.

The go-ahead score came with 0:52 left in overtime: Bo Horvat Goal (23) Snap Shot, assists: Mathew Barzal (34), Matthew Schaefer (23). The lead changed hands 3 times. The Islanders won despite being outshot 35-23.

Score by period

Pittsburgh Penguins and New York Islanders, score by period
Team123OTT
PIT12104
NYI20215

W: Sorokin · L: Skinner

Scoring plays

First Period

  1. PITGoal · 12:09Anthony Mantha Goal (20) Snap Shot, assists: Justin Brazeau (12)1-0
  2. NYIGoal · 18:41Bo Horvat Goal (22) Backhand, assists: Anders Lee (20)1-1
  3. NYIGoal · 19:56Matthew Schaefer Goal (16) Slap Shot, assists: Ondrej Palat (8), Bo Horvat (15)1-2

Second Period

  1. PITGoal · 3:52Egor Chinakhov Goal (11) Snap Shot, assists: Thomas Novak (20), Erik Karlsson (31)2-2
  2. PITGoal · 14:09Bryan Rust Goal (19) Wrist Shot, assists: Sidney Crosby (32), Ilya Solovyov (4)3-2

Third Period

  1. NYIGoal · 8:37Mathew Barzal Goal (16) Slap Shot, assists: Adam Pelech (7)3-3
  2. PITGoal · 10:40Justin Brazeau Goal (15) Tip-In, assists: Brett Kulak (8)4-3
  3. NYIGoal · 15:24Ryan Pulock Goal (3) Snap Shot, assists: Mathew Barzal (33), Simon Holmstrom (16)4-4

Overtime

  1. NYIGoal · 0:52Bo Horvat Goal (23) Snap Shot, assists: Mathew Barzal (34), Matthew Schaefer (23)4-5

Team stats

PITNYI
Shots
35
23
Power Play Goals
0
0
Faceoff Win Percent
44.6
55.4
Hits
25
22
Blocked Shots
10
12
Penalty Minutes
4
4

Top performers

Pittsburgh PenguinsNew York Islanders

Goals

Justin Brazeau1
Bo Horvat2

Assists

Justin Brazeau1
Mathew Barzal2

Points

Justin Brazeau2
Bo Horvat3

Player stats

Penguins · Forwards

PlayerBSHTTK+/-TOIGASSOGFO%PIM
Noel Acciari C010013:15002057.10
Justin Brazeau RW210212:5911600.00
Egor Chinakhov RW010-116:4710300.00
Sidney Crosby C030018:17013061.52
Connor Dewar C112013:2200200.00
Ben Kindel C100114:13002020.00
Blake Lizotte C020011:0500000.00
Evgeni Malkin C013-217:4400300.00
Anthony Mantha RW110113:3110200.00
Tommy Novak C000-214:18012027.30
Rickard Rakell RW010016:4100100.00
Bryan Rust RW010-119:0510100.00

Penguins · Defense

PlayerBSHTTK+/-TOIGASSOGFO%PIM
Connor Clifton D060-116:2700100.00
Erik Karlsson D010222:2701300.02
Brett Kulak D100-220:2301000.00
Ryan Shea D100-220:5000200.00
Ilya Solovyov D022114:1201200.00
Parker Wotherspoon D331123:0000000.00

Penguins · Goalies

PlayerGASASVSV%TOIPIM
Stuart Skinner G52318.78360:520

Islanders · Forwards

PlayerBSHTTK+/-TOIGASSOGFO%PIM
Mathew Barzal C000424:16124050.00
Casey Cizikas C100014:49001069.20
Jonathan Drouin LW100-211:58001050.00
Anthony Duclair LW000-13:0400000.00
Marc Gatcomb C030-112:4400000.00
Emil Heineman LW000-315:4500000.00
Simon Holmstrom RW001218:0901100.00
Bo Horvat C220524:35213050.00
Anders Lee LW040114:4701200.00
Kyle MacLean C010-111:170010100.00
Jean-Gabriel Pageau C040-215:40000050.00
Ondrej Palat LW000114:5101100.00

Islanders · Defense

PlayerBSHTTK+/-TOIGASSOGFO%PIM
Tony DeAngelo D010222:0900200.00
Scott Mayfield D032-113:3900100.02
Adam Pelech D100120:1201200.00
Ryan Pulock D430-120:4310200.00
Matthew Schaefer D300127:5911200.00
Carson Soucy D010-112:2900000.02

Islanders · Goalies

PlayerGASASVSV%TOIPIM
Ilya Sorokin G43531.88660:220

Three stars

  1. Bo Horvat (NYI)
  2. Mathew Barzal (NYI)
  3. Ryan Pulock (NYI)

Scores, stats and closing line: ESPN. Prediction-market prices: Kalshi and Polymarket. Betting splits: a consensus across several sportsbooks. Odds change constantly: confirm the price at the book. 21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Game details updated Oct 13, 6:06 PM ET. How game pages are made